19The Foolish And The Brave by Rocky
I selected it under DS9; I'll select it for overall. This is what ST fic is about, the process of redeeming or filling in the holes of an ep, in this case 'The Valiant'.
-- Rob Morris - Wed, 16 Apr 2003 11:58:01 -0400

24Dvorovoi by Karen Page
This was a well crafted story.I enjoyed readingit and did want to find out what happened in theend.After a slowish start the pace really picked up so by the time Picard,Deanna and Bailey were chasing after Beverly we had a full blown thriller.It was also a good study of the power of an abusiverelationship which was made explicit at one point witha reference to Devon as a wife beater. That's exactlywhat he was in his ability to make Bailey feel guiltywhen she acted independently, quite apart from hispossessive behaviour and his temper. The author also created an interesting and believablecharacter in Bailey.Despite her apparent strength herinsecurity from her childhood traumas made it easy forDevon to keep his grip on her using another classicabuser's trick - to make their victim think that they areonly worth something through their relationship withthe abuser and that no one else wants them.
-- Rose Evans - Wed, 16 Apr 2003 17:54:57 -0400

10Kindred Spirits by Gamin Davis
Gamin has been a excellent writer for as long as I've known her (over ten years), even if I don't always agree with everything she says in her stuff. But she does it well enough most of the time so that I'm at least willing to suspend my disbelief long enough to enjoy the story.In this case, however, I have to agree fully with her. Next to TOS, VOY is the only Trek show that has a Vulcan as a regular character--and one cannot help but make comparisons between Kirk and Spock and Janeway and Tuvok, which is understandable, since they tend to be portrayed in a similar manner on each of the given shows, even if Tuvok *is* technically simply Janeway's Security Chief and not First Officer, as Spock is with Kirk. Regarding KINDRED SPIRITS, a dream sequence where the four actually sit down for a private talk, truly illustrates the profound similarities between them. It's her first attempt at doing something besides TOS exclusively, and I must say it's one of the best "first attempts" I have ever read, if not *the* best. I have told her more than once that she has got to expand on this somehow, figure a way to do a longer story where the four actually work together in some way or something like that--and not have it be a dream sequence.It's not easy to figure a way to do that without using time-worn plot devices, of course, such as the Guardian (time-travel) or wormholes into another sector of the Galaxy or something. But knowing her writing talent as I do, I firmly believe that Gamin will eventually come up with something--and I, for one, will love reading it first once she fin- ishes it (as I usually do). Meanwhile, this marvelous little dream sequence vignette will have to suffice.
-- Debra Wimer - Wed, 16 Apr 2003 23:43:56 -0400

31The Ritual by Mara Greengrass
This story just made me giggle, even the 3rd time I read it. ;) I think Mara has advanced skills in tormenting poor Hoshi.
-- Taryn Eve - Thu, 17 Apr 2003 19:09:46 -0400

74Where is the Fic? by Jemima
LOL! Very amusing filk. It perfectly calls up the frustrations of those of us readers stuck in WIP-ville.
-- Taryn Eve - Thu, 17 Apr 2003 19:12:28 -0400

50Time Standing Still I & II by Tracy Thurman
I really liked Part One. It was very angsty. The 2nd part intrigued me and I liked the idea of the mind link gone kablewie, a good example of how technology can never make up for the missteps of the heart. I hope there's a part 3, but in a way, I like seeing them stuck in that moment.
-- Taryn Eve - Thu, 17 Apr 2003 19:18:44 -0400

52Together Again for the First Time by Bill Livingston
LOL! Poor McCoy! The drabble captured Jadzia's slyness in a very amusing way.
-- Taryn Eve - Thu, 17 Apr 2003 19:22:10 -0400

13Knock Three times by PH in NH
A nice, humorous dose of R/S. I liked the way they got around their Tucker situation. LOL.
-- Taryn Eve - Thu, 17 Apr 2003 19:32:50 -0400

62Blood Debt by Djinn
When I look back at the fic I've read over 2001, this one keeps coming back to me for a variety of reasons. The interactions, the dialogue, the intensity, cruelty, the tension, the emotional undercurrent, the subtle violence - both psychological and physical - are all beautifully written without being heavy-handed or overly dramatic. Djinn's deft writing skills carefully peel away the layers of Valeris, Saavik, and even Spock, doing a marvelous job of showing rather than telling. In terms of character, this story doesn't hold back when it comes to Valeris or Saavik. It was also nice to see Sela again here - though 'nice' is not exactly the first word that comes to mind when thinking of Djinn's Sela. Sela here is controlling, jealous and maybe even brutal. This is a meaty and memorable story that continues to haunt the reader, long after the last paragraph is read. It's definitely one of those fanfics to add to a "must read" list.
-- Seema - Fri, 18 Apr 2003 10:24:47 -0400

4Day of the Dead by Djinn
Ah, this story is by far my favorite J/C story of this year. Djinn deftly weaves myth with reality as she creates an entirely believable, intelligent and haunting romance tinged with regret. Janeway and Chakotay are both written beautifully here. Their dialogue was emotional but not sappy. My favorite part of that particular conversation is the mention of the Angry Warrior and the mutual acknowledgement of a relationship that never quite got off the ground despite the longing from both individuals. The scenes, the vivid and evocative descriptions - all of this is written to perfection. Djinn does an exceptional job of setting the mood and scene. The twist at the end is not forced but flows perfectly and on rereading, holds up really well. This is a story I've read several times but it feels fresh and new each time I taken a look at it as there is something new to discover with every reading. Yet another outstanding story from Djinn.
-- Seema - Fri, 18 Apr 2003 10:31:35 -0400

2Janeway: The Musical! by Jemima
I would be absolutely remiss if I didn't acknowledge the brilliance, the ambition and the style of Jemima's "Janeway! The Musical." Filking a single song is one thing, but Jemima undertook to filk "The Man of La Mancha", which is an absolutely amazing and brave undertaking. It goes without saying that all of the individual filks in this musical scan wonderfully, but there are lovely and memorable moments in each, such as the crew wondering why all the stews taste exactly the same, and perhaps Janeway doth protest too much when she 'sings' "I'm only thinking of them" and wistfully considers her non-relationship with Chakotay. While Janeway figures prominently in the majority of the individual filks, everyone gets their turn on stage and it's nice to see some of the classic friendships like Chakotay and Torres. Some of the filks also support individual episodes like "Fair Haven" or "Caretaker." Definitely one of the most impressive works I've seen this year.
-- Seema - Fri, 18 Apr 2003 10:38:33 -0400

51On the Madhouse Boards by Lori
This is a highly ambitious and intelligent novel. From the very first line to the last, it's a gripping and complex plot. Lori has a wonderful way with Picard and Troi. She makes an unlikely pairing believable and it helps that she really does believe in their relationship and this love for the characters translates into wonderful characterizations. In addition, she writes aliens who are three-dimensional and truly original in their conception and form. The story premise is that Picard is badly wounded and Deanna has to take control of the Enterprise while still keeping her emotions under check. I love the way Lori writes Troi here - Deanna is every bit the professional and competent Starfleet officer. In addition, she's also a wife deeply wounded by her husband's rejection of her. The two personas are skillfully blended together. This is truly a magnificent novel - one that blends a deep and loving relationship with an intricate plot.
-- Seema - Fri, 18 Apr 2003 10:41:08 -0400

5The Albatross by Christinecgb
ChristineCGB has such a lovely, lyrical flow to her writing and this story isn't an exception. I love the initial dynamic between Chakotay and Seven - the 'trying' and the distance, both. Christine has such a gift for putting in only the details that really matter, of adding only those elements that actually contribute to a story. There is nothing excessive about this fic, nothing maudlin or overdramatic. It's a perfect – and poignant – example of how to 'show' a relationship – both one that's deteriorating and one that already has. Possibly the highlight of this fanfic is the painful honesty of the conversation between Janeway and Chakotay. I couldn't help but hurt for both of them and that's truly the power of Christine's story – the ability to punch the reader in the gut. Christine says this is possibly her last J/C fanfic, but I seriously hope it's not her swan song because her 'writing voice' in VOY fanfic is truly memorable.
-- Seema - Fri, 18 Apr 2003 10:47:20 -0400

69Weeds by Rabble Rouser
This story, "Weeds" by RabbleRouser, is an amazing portrait of Marla and her relationship with Khan and of course, with those whom she left behind on Enterprise. The journey Marla takes from the very first paragraph to the last is beautifully told with evocative language and is especially more poignant because it's in Marla's own voice, so we get to hear exactly what she's thinking and feeling at the same time she does. The storytelling technique used here – that of Marla relating events into her logs – is classic Trek but used so much more effectively. Marla's awe at first seeing Khan – calling him a "my man out of the past" and the language surrounding that initial meeting is just absolutely some of the most memorable writing and makes me wish I could write like that. RR ratchets up the intensity as the story continues until it's obvious how deep Marla's pain and guilt run. Chilling and haunting right down to the very last word, this is a marvelous story and comes highly recommended and shouldn't missed.
-- Seema - Fri, 18 Apr 2003 10:55:56 -0400

85Crossing the Desert by Djinn
This is the first Chapel story I've read. It does a good job of giving depth to a character I didn't know that well from TOS. Also, I really liked McCoy's bit at the end.
-- Taryn Eve - Sat, 19 Apr 2003 11:08:26 -0400

78Cherry Sno-Cones by Tracy Thurman
I liked the details of Trip noticing Natalie's dress. It made the scene more vivid. I also liked the way that Tracy brought Desert Crossing full circle ("Tell me what you want!") by having Archer hand over the sno-cone.
-- Taryn Eve - Sat, 19 Apr 2003 11:14:15 -0400

81Coffee Fiend by janezy
Amusing story. Liked Chakotay's solution to Janeway's problem, and I loved the details of how she became the coffee fiend.
-- Taryn Eve - Sat, 19 Apr 2003 11:17:36 -0400

25Act of War by Seema
This story has got everything a reader could ask for--fast-paced exciting drama, excellent characterization and compelling dialogue and narrative. It's effective as both a stand alone or as part of the Glory Days series. No matter how many times I read it, I find myself caught up in the story and the ending is just as wrenching. I think this story is truly among the best, if not *the* best of the year.
-- Rocky - Mon, 21 Apr 2003 05:48:53 -0400

61Blink by Seema
This powerful portrait of Kira in her resistance days beautifully illustrates how she became the woman we met on DS9. The setting is highly evocative, and the dialogue conveys so many different meanings on so many levels. A wonderful story, and one that deserves top honors.
-- Rocky - Mon, 21 Apr 2003 05:50:40 -0400

62Blood Debt by Djinn
This is one of those stories that stays with you for a long, long time after you finish reading it, both for its compelling character portraits as well as the searing images with which Djinn gets her point across.
-- Rocky - Mon, 21 Apr 2003 05:51:39 -0400

51On the Madhouse Boards by Lori
It's very rare to find such a long, multi-textured work on the newsgroup anymore. Madhouse is an outstanding story which conveys so much, on so many levels. I've long since 'bought' the Picard/Troi relationship thanks to Lori's previous C & C stories, but this one brings in an entirely new dimension. I also love how 'alien' the aliens are and how the reader is kept guessing as to who the 'good guys' truly are.
-- Rocky - Mon, 21 Apr 2003 05:53:39 -0400

65Utoto by Wildcat
I've said it before, but it bears repeating: no one writes Spock and Uhura as well, and as compellingly, as Wildcat. I love this latest addition to the long-running S/U series. Every time I think Wildcat has said about all she can regarding this relationship, she brings out another development or nuance. As always, all of the characterizations are very well done and the storyline itself is incredibly poignant, leading as it does to inevitable tragedy.
-- Rocky - Mon, 21 Apr 2003 05:55:48 -0400

4The Absinthe Heart by Seema
Quark pov is unusual. Seema makes it work, and it's doubly impressive that she writes in second person, and present tense, and somehow, all of that fits together so well. The voices of the characters are spot-on.
-- Lori - Mon, 21 Apr 2003 22:28:26 -0400

24The Lamne'rau by Jemima
There was a backstory left untold when 'The Raven' came into being, and Jemima tells the story in a straighforward yet chilling fashion that gives us a Magnus and Erin Hansen who are just normal enough to be sympathetic, yet skewed enough that they would go chasing after aliens only heard about through the intelligence grapevine -- which is one of the many logical explanations Jemima comes up with that TPTB never thought to make for the timing of the Hansens' journey. Annika is a believably normal little girl who proves to have an eerie gift for prophecy. All in all, an excellent, well-crafted short piece that ties up Seven's childhood pre-Borg neatly and believably.
-- Lori - Mon, 21 Apr 2003 22:54:06 -0400

94It Wouldn't Be Make-Believe by Djinn
Djinn's novel about Vic Fontaine's origins, adventures, and romance is well-told and true to his voice. Everything here makes sense and rings true to what I've seen of the DS9 characters and situations. I've always had difficulty with android and/or hologram fanfic - too difficult to suspend disbelief as the character acts too much like a human being. There's no such trouble here. Vic's a hologram, and Djinn never lets us forget it, and yet, he captures the reader's sympathies and takes us along with him. I never once tripped over something I found unbelievable, and that's the measure of a good story -- not that all of it's totally believable, but that the author is skilled enough to make you believe from the first page to the last that everything between is believable and true. And by the end, I wished it could have gone better for Vic, but it was a fitting way for Djinn to cap off a wonderful story.
-- Lori - Mon, 21 Apr 2003 23:09:35 -0400

21Life In The Fast Lane by Rocky
This is just...wow. It's just so good. The dialogue is spot-on, the words are perfect. And it drags you in so quickly.
-- nostalgia - Mon, 21 Apr 2003 23:27:49 -0400

4The Absinthe Heart by Seema
*sniff* Beautiful. I didn't think QuarkFic would appeal to me, but I'm glad I read this. Utterly wonderful.
-- nostalgia - Mon, 21 Apr 2003 23:29:03 -0400

69Weeds by Rabble Rouser
One of the most powerful stories of the year, this portrait of Kahn through the eyes of Marla McGivers has got to rank up there as one of the best reads. All of the characterizations are exactly right and Rabble Rouser does an amazing job of allowing us to understand Marla, her motivations and desires, and to see clearly through her eyes. No excuses are offered, but that only adds to the powerful message conveyed.
-- Rocky - Tue, 22 Apr 2003 10:56:26 -0400

51Beautiful by Seema
Because it really was. This is a gorgeous story. I missed out on commenting on it in the Mis category which is a shame because I would gladly have commented twice. It's one of Seema's best and I think one of the best of the year. It's a bittersweet story capturing all that's sad and beautiful about being a legend in your own lifetime - and then finding someone to share that feeling with you. It's a very visual story with all the stilted moments being played out in tight focus. I could be a Janeway/ Picard shipper - just give me more like this.
-- Christinecgb - Tue, 22 Apr 2003 10:58:20 -0400

47Glory Days by Rocky
Every so often, a story comes along and when I read it, I think, "I wish I wrote that!" That's exactly how I feel about "Glory Days" by Rocky. This is one of my favorite Rocky fics ever. The Tom and Harry friendship is so beautifully drawn here and their interactions post-Endgame are extremely realistic and beautiful. I love the slightly cynical Tom and the more upbeat Harry. The mood between them is really well written. One of my favorite stories of the year definitely.
-- Seema - Sat, 26 Apr 2003 23:17:36 -0400

48Going Away by Boadicea and Kelly
This is an amazing story. Both from a structural viewpoint as well as a writing one. Each drabble flows from one to another and the writing is consistent, beautiful, and lyrical. I love the sensuality of this piece, though the threesome here might not be the most obvious or the sexiest. This fic is completely serious and lovely throughout. Gorgeous, gorgeous work.
-- Seema - Sat, 26 Apr 2003 23:19:21 -0400

78You're Lucky I'm A Civilised Man by Paula Stiles
I love this story. Alex Sawalha is one of the most interesting OCs I've ever read and this story is absolutely riveting from first paragraph to the last. I enjoyed seeing some familiar faces again - Riker, Ro, O'Brien and Bashir. The interaction between Alex and his wife, T'Nar, was very well-written as well. This is an excellent story, carefully paced and it pulls the reader right into the narrative.
-- Seema - Sat, 26 Apr 2003 23:44:03 -0400

30Alone by Djinn
I disapprove of this test category but (henceforth to be abbreviated as IDOTTCB) I have to vote for this story. It's impossible to pick a favorite out of a year of Djinn, never mind a year of so many good writers, but if I had to guess I'd say Alone was my favorite for the year.
-- Jemima - Sun, 27 Apr 2003 22:38:34 -0400

37Monday Morning at the Anti-Matter Cooler by Jungle Kitty
IDOTTCB the image of radioactive water rising around these insults to red shirts everywhere is permanently burned in my mind.
-- Jemima - Sun, 27 Apr 2003 22:42:30 -0400

46Not All At Once by Djinn
IDOTTCB I have to vote for Khan. What a lovely genocidal maniac Djinn has made him!
-- Jemima - Sun, 27 Apr 2003 22:43:51 -0400

51On the Madhouse Boards by Lori
IDOTTCB Lori has done it again. She has a way with aliens and with the vanilla characters of TNG.
-- Jemima - Sun, 27 Apr 2003 22:45:33 -0400

58Perfection Is As Perfection Does by Rocky
IDOTTCB this was a great parody of the classic time-travel parentage paradox.
-- Jemima - Sun, 27 Apr 2003 22:48:34 -0400

23The Heart of the Matter by Seema
IDOTTCB this was my favorite story by Seema this year. I loved the subtle clues to Seven's state of mind.
-- Jemima - Sun, 27 Apr 2003 22:52:26 -0400

69Weeds by Rabble Rouser
IDOTTCB "Weeds" was riveting, even though I knew what would happen in the end. (I didn't follow the directions - I read Djinn's sequel first.) The story made me think about Marla's motives and her professor's theories, and made me want to go out and write my own Marla story. That's the best kind of fanfic.
-- Jemima - Sun, 27 Apr 2003 22:57:53 -0400

5The Albatross by Christinecgb
IDOTTCB this was the best goodbye fic J/C could ask for. Thanks again to Christine for one more fic above and beyond the call of duty.
-- Jemima - Sun, 27 Apr 2003 22:59:58 -0400

62Blood Debt by Djinn
This is perhaps my favorite fanfic. Ever. I love its mystery, characterization, plot twists, uniqueness, story...sheesh, I just can't seem to think of all the adjectives to describe it, but I love this story! I guess 'nough said.
-- Jerie - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 17:27:07 -0400

12A New Kind of Ordinary by Sara Goose
A very lovely story that made me interested in a pairing I never would have cared for otherwise. I love Deanna in this one, and I laughed at the aliens becoming upset by dancing! :-)
-- Elise - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 18:56:56 -0400

30Alone by Djinn
One of my favourite Seven stories! So touching and heartbreaking... yet hopeful. I love the way Djinn uses the word Alone. This is a fantastic story.
-- Elise - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 19:00:23 -0400

2A Bootprint On the Pants by Bill Livingston
A short, and telling, meditation on Riker's, Picard's and Janeway's different views about Captaincy.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 19:27:13 -0400

23Accidental Suicide by Christinecgb
This is an odd, haunting story about two driven women and what happens when one of them disappears, possibly forever.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 20:13:22 -0400

26Adagio by Cait N.
LOL! Cute first Janeway/Chakotay meeting!
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 20:18:37 -0400

47ASC Awards 2001 Dinner by Djinn Seema and Stephen Ratliff
This was a fun capper to last year's Awards--all the old faces, all the places and a few new jokes.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 20:27:45 -0400

58Birth of the Federation by monkee
ROTFL! Can I have the recipe for that pie?
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 20:34:07 -0400

59Blast From The Past by Kath (Trekkigrrl)
Whoohoo! A feisty Christine Chapel is always a good thing. And one who is feisty in Spock's presence? Even better! If you prefer your TOS to be a Plomeek-Soup-free Zone, then check this one out.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 20:38:46 -0400

61Blink by Seema
Dark and chilling. This portrait of Kira the terrorist and one of her victims during the Resistance era will scare you and make you rethink the character.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 20:42:16 -0400

63Blooper Reel by Monkee and the VS 7.5 Writing staff
Bwahahaha! A blooper reel for a Virtual Season? What a brilliant idea! I wish I'd thought of it! This one was a real hoot.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 20:44:26 -0400

67Breach of Protocol by K. M. Wilcox
LOL! A funny, evil drabble with a killer punchline.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 20:51:56 -0400

68Bridges by Djinn
To comment on one of the Carter stories is almost to comment on them all, but this is a good, transitional one. Lots of nasty things come out in the wash, which makes it a very satisfying read for anyone who has read up to that point.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 21:01:47 -0400

70Cat Tale by zoinky
ROTFL! Poor, poor fishy! This is short and not-so-sweet for poor Livingstone.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 21:03:08 -0400

72Catfight in a Hot Vulcan Desert by Ventura33
This is an absolutely hilarious take-off of every soap opera mudfight ever made, with a hefty dollop of lesbian feminism dropped right in. Great timing, truly evil characterisation. A memorable one for all the delightfully wrong reasons.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 21:05:37 -0400

86Cybernetic Cadet 4: Freshman Keg Party by Ventura33
The road to cultural assimilation doth not go well for one cadet in this series about a Borg at Starfleet Academy. The payback moment is fun.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 21:10:41 -0400

7Dear Miss Lovelorn by Jungle Kitty
ROTFL! Priceless! Utterly priceless! Skewers some of Trek's sillier storylines and the voices are spot on.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 21:12:56 -0400

30Emigre by Mark Russel Stanley
Poor Bashir finds out just what it's like to be an exile. Thank God he's got Garak to show him the ropes. Mark makes even this B/Ez fan like the idea of Bashir and Garak getting together.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 21:19:38 -0400

49Golden Gateways by Sara Goose
An intriguing look at a neglected part of Trek future history and a portrait of one of the people who founded the Federation.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 21:22:51 -0400

61Her Strut by monkee
This one was a funny, but also thoughtful look at just how everyone on Enterprise sees T'Pol, and how different those viewpoints are. A good word portrait of her is built up from different points of view, even the "The Subservient Quadruped"!
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 21:26:05 -0400

75How Kirk Should Have Gone Out by the Phantom
This is how Kirk really should have gone out--especially if they were going to waste the other TOS characters the way that they did.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 21:28:36 -0400

80Immortality Denied by Rob Morris
I liked this solution. It's nasty (and if you look carefully at histories, you'll see they already do it to a certain extent) but fitting.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 21:29:52 -0400

94It Wouldn't Be Make-Believe by Djinn
I didn't like this one as much as some of Djinn's others, but it still succeeded as a sad, soulful story about an unusual pairing. And Vic comes off very, very well. Much more three-dimensional than on the show.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 21:31:52 -0400

20Dream Until Your Dream Comes True by Djinn
A very dark look at one of Djinn's favourite pairings. I particularly liked how the repetition of the first paragraph as the last paragraph made me rethink the entire story.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 21:33:22 -0400

96I've Grown Accustomed to the Phage by Jemima
Maybe it's just because I can't stand the Vidiians, but I thought this was absolutely hilarious! And it scans, too!
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 21:35:30 -0400

15La Belle Dame Sans Regrets by Temporal Rift
I liked this P/C story. It was sweet, and it was nice to see this pairing get the happy ending that it never got in canon.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 21:38:06 -0400

17Legacy Year 1 by Valerie Shearer
This is one that Valerie has been working on for a while, both the parent and a reworking of her superlative "Surrender". It's an AU, like the previous story, and, as usual with Valerie, a much darker, more realistic vision of the Dominion War and its costs than TPTB showed us.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 21:40:53 -0400

19Lesstosterone by Bill Livingston
ROTFL! Poor Tom! When will he ever learn?
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 21:42:01 -0400

23Listen: there's a hell of a good universe next door; let's go by Alara Rogers
I quite liked this one. Two characters whom we rarely see have a little talk about what being omnipotent *really* means. Very nice to see Amanda again, even worth bringing Charlie into it (thank God! At first, I thought he was Tremayne!).
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 21:44:58 -0400

22Like We Never Had A Broken Heart by Djinn
This is a dark, bitter, unflinching look at a very unusual pairing--and boy, is it hot!
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 21:47:14 -0400

26Living in Ashes by Djinn
You'd think, after the first of this pairing, Djinn would sit back on her laurels. But no, she does it again--and even though you know it will all end in tears, you keep hoping it won't.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 21:48:41 -0400

37Monday Morning at the Anti-Matter Cooler by Jungle Kitty
ROTFL! This is one of the funniest stories of the year. These ladies are complete morons, total Kirk groupies. And the last few lines are a hoot!
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 21:50:15 -0400

39Nacelles of Desire by Jungle Kitty
Heehee! Lovely skewering of slash (and not-so-slash) clich้s of the young and terminally plot-challenged. I can absolutely see why someone would have not realised it was a parody at first. It's dead on.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 21:51:37 -0400

46Not All At Once by Djinn
This is one of the most chilling and horrifying stories of the year. You almost feel sorry for Khan and he's the villain of the piece--sort of. This is a superlative follow up to Rabble Rouser's story about Khan's snakepit and it's just as good.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 22:35:04 -0400

66Pride Day by Mark Russel Stanley
This was so damned funny! Mary Sues may be irritating, but Stark Manley's are an entirely different order of magnitude. And Mark still manages to get half the possible slash pairings into it (the last line is priceless). More! More!
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 22:37:20 -0400

93Shakedown Cruise by Michael Roy Hollihan
This was an enjoyable and intriguing beginning to a brand new MIS series. We have a captain who wants to be Kirk, but doesn't quite have the ego, and thank God for that. Another one that begs for a sequel.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 22:38:57 -0400

94She Blinded Me by Cait N.
[snort!] Beware of jilted half-Klingons looking to get laid. When will Harry ever learn?
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 22:40:43 -0400

82Returning Home by Matt Edwards
This melancholy tale shows the other side of Starfleet at war, away from all the celebrations and medals and the dodgy policies of admirals. Not one of our usual heroes, but he could be, on a bad day.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 22:49:40 -0400

7The Babe A Week Club by Rabble Rouser and Djinn
A rolicking satire about the unfortunate Paramount tendency to create great female characters and strangle them in spandex. Also a cracking collaboration between Rabble Rouser and Djinn. Worth more than one read.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 22:51:24 -0400

24The Lamne'rau by Jemima
There were a couple quite dark stories about Seven this year and this was one of them. This is a Seven childhood story that starts out broad and adventuresome and ends in a very chill, dark, claustrophobic space.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 22:56:00 -0400

44This Time Of The Month by Ventura33
Hehe. A short and sweet warning to those adventuresome Kirk types who refuse to go use protection. As this little piece proves, the protection is not always for the guy.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 22:57:57 -0400

69Weeds by Rabble Rouser
This tale takes a minor, and pretty obnoxious and whiny, guest character from TOS and not only makes her sympathetic, but does so by giving her her comeuppance (while she gives Khan his). A most deservedly-praised story this year.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 23:01:16 -0400

74Where is the Fic? by Jemima
ROTFL! Oh, this was funny, and oh, so very true. Many of us have created the crime detailed in this filk, which is a cautionary tale about overreaching oneself indeed!
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 23:02:39 -0400

75Who's Afraid of Intendant Kira? by Kathryn Ramage
A snappy, bitter rendition of a sixties' classic. The Mirror Universe lends itself remarkably well to this adaptation and we actually find a little depth to the Intendant and Mirror-Garak.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 23:05:18 -0400

108Stockholm Syndrome by nostalgia
Ice cold and more-than-creepy, this Seven POV adheres strictly to canon while going where no Trek canon or profic would ever go. A strong, nasty look at a culture clash with no winners.
-- Paula Stiles - Tue, 29 Apr 2003 22:47:50 -0400

81Impress by Kelly
I didn't get in in time to comment about this story in the MIS section, which sucks because it *is* one of my favourites for the year and deserves reams of praise. I don't know whether it's because I have this particular fondness for Janeway-through-the-eyes-of-another stories or whether it's because it's Kai Winn perfectly done or whether it's because the thought of these two women is just too damn delivicious. All three, I suspect. I read this story what must be nearly a year ago and I still remember the tone and this unmistakeable Kai Winn voice that expresses her delusion and her arrogance so well. And what is additionally impressive is the way is the seduction in the story - not of Janeway or Kai Winn, but of the reader. It's a sexy story that draws you in to something you probably never thought about until you encountered it here. And you wind up seduced. "Impress" indeed.
-- Christinecgb - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 03:24:32 -0400

24The Lamne'rau by Jemima
There's a lot of Trek I've only just caught up on due to the ASCs and this is one of those stories that I'm sorry to have not read before. I feel like it deserved more time, more feedback and just a general dialogue with other over the many theories suggested in it. I marvel at Jemima's ability to mix science fiction with stories about real people and Trek could probably learn a thing or two from her. I also love what she had done for the Borg - in Trek they were reasonably two dimensional - the ultimate *bad*. Jemima gives their existence meaning, makes it something that is desirable and nourishing, albeit on a level we might not understand. Jemima also has a feel for a mythic tale which is one of the reasons why i think this story makes a fabulous candidate for best story of the year: it has an epic quality - hinting at deeper meanings and *bigger* things. It's one of those stories that give you a little chill at the end and makes me wish to god I could write stories with plot. She finishes it off with a great line where Annika "discovered what it meant to come home." And yes, yes, yes to that. If you haven't read it, for god's sake do so.
-- Christinecgb - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 03:34:17 -0400

47Thrive by Jemima
I think I'll embarass Jemima one more time by suggesting another of her stories for story of the year. This is my favourite Jemima story. Granted, it doesn't have the epic quality of the Lamne'ru but I love it because it's a beautiful story from a write who by admission doesn't like to do this sort of thing. It's a thoughtful Janeway, a likeable Chakotay with (gasp!) depth and yet another treatment of the Borg as a complex idea. As the instigator of this challenge, I am proud to lay a little claim to this. Thanks for that, Jemima.
-- Christinecgb - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 03:39:32 -0400

34An Elegant Solution by Rocky
This is an excellent story, and a very interesting take on Janeway's promotion. Very close to how I pictured it myself. And, of course, Rocky never disappoints, with her wonderful writing style and great characterization of the admirals.
-- Elise - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 04:07:54 -0400

39And Baby Makes Five by Seema
This is a hilarious story that definitely puts Seema among the best badfic authors ever! :-)
-- Elise - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 04:20:53 -0400

51Beautiful by Seema
Strange and unusual pairings attract me, and this is no exception. Seema writes Janeway/Picard it in a way that makes it seem completely natural. This is great!
-- Elise - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 04:27:32 -0400

23Drowning in a Strawberry Daiquiri by Sara Goose
Wonderful story, with so much going on beneath the surface. Nice!
-- Elise - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 04:35:36 -0400

43Forbidden Love by Seema
Definitely one of my favourite stories with this pairing! :-) Hilarious!
-- Elise - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 04:38:30 -0400

49Golden Gateways by Sara Goose
This is definitely one of my favourite stories of all time. It might be short, but it's filled with so much sorrow and hope. Lovely!
-- Elise - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 04:42:50 -0400

108Stockholm Syndrome by nostalgia
Wow, this story blew me away. Very intriguing idea, almost humorous, but chilling all the same.
-- Elise - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 04:58:13 -0400

25Act of War by Seema
Seema really delivered a punch with this one, and it provided a distinctive turning point in the Glory Days universe. All that, plus it's beautifully written and very touching.
-- Sara - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 12:42:42 -0400

55Beta Energy by Jemima
Jemima did a wonderful job with this hysterical story!
-- Sara - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 12:45:57 -0400

60Blemishes by Lori
Although I really did love "Nemesis," Lori's inspired parody sill makes me laugh out loud practically whenever I remember the appearance of Mulder and Scully and the multitude of anvils.
-- Sara - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 12:48:09 -0400

4Day of the Dead by Djinn
"Day of the Dead" is just a perfect ghost story, and is really a touching and tragic romantic tale.
-- Sara - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 12:50:46 -0400

70Home Again by Tori Morris
I still can't get over how this story is able to grasp such history and feeling and distill it into such a small space. With just a few words, Tori leads her reader from cautious to happy to sad, and then she makes them want more.
-- Sara - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 12:54:13 -0400

94It Wouldn't Be Make-Believe by Djinn
Djinn manages to transform what was always an entertaining character into a very real and three dimensional one. I especially like the darker side to this one, with the influences of Section 31 and the results of that.
-- Sara - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 12:57:41 -0400

51On the Madhouse Boards by Lori
A complex and meaty novel that is without parallel in my opinion. Lori did a fantastic job on this one and I really can't wait until I have a chance to read it again.
-- Sara - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 13:01:08 -0400

65Utoto by Wildcat
It's been nearly a year since I first discovered Wildcat's Spock/Uhura series and was perfectly enchanted by it. "Utoto" is a wonderful story and I'm very glad I decided to take a chance on the whole universe!
-- Sara - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 13:04:46 -0400

14Do the Walls Come Down by Seema
Do the Walls Come Down has some excellent interaction between Janeway and Paris, and it's a great start to the Glory Days series. I especially like the thought that while the Voyager crew would be considered the "returning heroes", people would still remember that they weren't there for the Dominion War. Intriguing thought.
-- Elise - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 14:07:46 -0400

38Fire And Rain by Rocky
Fire and Rain is one my favourite stories in the Glory Days universe. Tuvok and B'Elanna make for a wonderful team. They're different, but there is still a deeper understanding between them. This story brings that out very nicely.
-- Elise - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 14:08:24 -0400

47Glory Days by Rocky
Harry finally got his promotion! :-) But aside from that this story made me feel sad. They didn't keep in touch, not for real. It's probably a very realistic view, despite having shared a lot, sooner or later people tend to drift apart. But it's still sad, and I'm glad to see Paris and Kim trying to work on this in the end.
-- Elise - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 14:09:15 -0400

64Hero by Rocky
It seems the Glory Days universe made a habit out of picking my favourite character combinations! Harry and Janeway certainly has an interesting connection, and it's nice to see it explored by such a good author.
-- Elise - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 14:09:40 -0400

16Latitude by Seema
Nice to see Caldik Prime be brought up again, however briefly. It would be odd if not *someone* in the AQ recognized Paris for that. I'm also a real sucker for seeing Paris and Chakotay in a friendly manner (well, actually, in *any* manner). Nice to see them finally talking for real.
-- Elise - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 14:10:40 -0400

21Life In The Fast Lane by Rocky
I might be slightly affected by the fact that this is about Seven, but I loved every sentence of Life in the Fast Lane. You can really feel the longing Seven's feels about not having seen Janeway for such a long time, and the beginnings of a distance between Chakotay and Seven. There is a certain sadness to this story, toned down, just below the surface. I like it a lot!
-- Elise - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 14:11:27 -0400

38The Sweetest Days by Seema
Beautiful and touching P/T interaction. It's little more than a random scene, a reunion after a brief time apart, but it still speaks volumes about their relationship and their emotions.
-- Elise - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 14:39:24 -0400

25Act of War by Seema
This story broke my heart. As it turned out, the next story in the series proved me wrong, but that doesn't make the emotional impact of this story any less. Terrific stuff!
-- Elise - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 14:40:07 -0400

31Empty Sky by Rocky & Seema
Another heartbreaking story. I could really feel the long, agonizing wait to find out who lived and who didn't. The ending, with Tom and his father, moved me deeply.
-- Elise - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 14:40:53 -0400

104Stand By Me by Rocky
Wonderful. Tuvok supporting Janeway, Janeway's guilt about surviving... it's all completely realistic, and very touching to that.
-- Elise - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 14:41:20 -0400

40ANGELS AND ASSASSINS by Invicta
I really enjoyed this story. Invicta showed why Dukat would prefer Bashir as an advocate rather than an actual attorney, which is absolutely essential to enjoying the story. Her explanation makes sense, and she also shows what Bashir has to go through to become the advocate Dukat needs.
-- Mark Stanley - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 17:28:25 -0400

56Have A Holly Jolly Unspecified Holiday by Paula Stiles
I love this filk! Political correctness gone mad makes it completely unsingable and hilarious.
-- Mark Stanley - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 17:30:43 -0400

8A Hairy Situation by Cait N.
I found this story tremendously entertaining. Not only is it an excellent Morn fic (of which there is far too little, if you ask me), but the original character's voice works well, too. Cait has been very clever here.
-- Kelly Chambliss - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 18:37:48 -0400

35Faith Part II: Forgiveness by Gabrielle Lawson
I don't remember what I said before and it's been even longer since I've read this story, but this is what I remember. As usual, the characters were right on key and although Bashir was different, he wasn't necessarily out of character, the plot, not the author changed him. This story was as riveting as the first and made you look forward to the next one. As usual, the story line was ingenius. Sorry, that's all I remember.
-- Meghan Elizabeth - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 18:38:52 -0400

56Have A Holly Jolly Unspecified Holiday by Paula Stiles
I really enjoyed this and it had a lesson too. It showed us how we take politically correctness too far. Brilliant.
-- Meghan Elizabeth - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 18:40:31 -0400

30Alone by Djinn
Not only is this story my favorite this year by Djinn, but it's one of my favorites overall. I love the way Djinn uses the precision of definition to help express Seven's chararacter. It makes such sense that Seven would try to explain her emotions by using a philological approach: its scientific elements would appeal to her and probably comfort her. Yet in no way is the story pedantic; in fact, it's a wonderfully moving portrayal of Seven.
-- Kelly Chambliss - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 18:43:13 -0400

17Legacy Year 1 by Valerie Shearer
I just finished this one as a matter of fact. It's brilliant. While reading, one wonders how such realism could be portrayed. It's obvious that a tremendous amount of reseach and effort went into it. The characters, even the original ones, come to life right before your eyes and before long, you know them as well as the ones from the series. The characters are real, making mistakes and doing what they need to in order to survive. Once again, Valerie has shown us the other side, and how things could have turned out.
-- Meghan Elizabeth - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 18:46:20 -0400

34An Elegant Solution by Rocky
Choosing just one "favorite" story by Rocky is hard enough in general, let alone during the "Glory Days" year. Yet here I am, about to cast my "favorite Rocky story" vote for a piece that isn't even in the Glory Days universe. But "An Elegant Solution" stands out for me because it's such a good example of Rocky's skill at creating pitch-perfect voices for essentially minor characters such as Admiral Nechayev. Through these characters, she also manages to convey so much about the larger canon universe and its major players.
-- Kelly Chambliss - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 18:49:07 -0400

66Pride Day by Mark Russel Stanley
If I remember correctly, this story ws better thean the original in many ways, however, I can't remember exactly why. The return of Stark was eagerly awaited and he didn't let us down. A very funny and original sequal.
-- Meghan Elizabeth - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 18:50:28 -0400

29all this is window dressing by not jenny
Although not jenny wrote only this one story in the Trekiverse, it's a memorable one. The point of view and the images have stayed with me, as has not jenny's vision of Janeway.
-- Kelly Chambliss - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 18:50:41 -0400

78You're Lucky I'm A Civilised Man by Paula Stiles
I normally don't read MIS stories, not having enough time. However, when I saw that Sawalha was in it, I decided to read. Paula did a great job at showing the real Sawalha underneath the professional we saw in the previous stories. Characters from other series were worked in brilliantly, especially Riker and Laren. I thought the conflict between the three was totally on key. All in all, a fantastic story.
-- Meghan Elizabeth - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 18:54:57 -0400

51Beautiful by Seema
Okay. It goes without saying that choosing just one Seema story is hell. But despite my fondness for "Do the Walls. . ." and "Latitude," I'm voting for "Beautiful" because of how poignantly and believably Seema has written a Janeway/Picard. As one would expect, Picard's voice is understated yet intense, and it's easy for the reader to share his attraction to Seema's Janeway.
-- Kelly Chambliss - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 18:56:08 -0400

19DoubleKat by Ventura33
You wouldn't think that a Janeway fanatic like me would balk at the idea of pairing Captain Janeway with Admiral Janeway from "Endgame." But since most such stories are just excuses for drooling kinkiness, I haven't been impressed. Until I read Ventura33's version. Unsurprisingly, this fine writer creates two excellent characters who are both separate yet the same. Yes, there's sex (and damned hot it is, too), but with an edge -- the issues the story raises are real, and the ending is very satisfying.
-- Kelly Chambliss - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 19:01:11 -0400

61Her Strut by monkee
I can't believe it. I'm about to vote for my favorite monkee story of the year -- and it isn't VOY! But "Her Strut" is such a virtuoso combination of multiple tones, points of view, and character voices that it stands out for me. By offering other characters' impressions of T'Pol, monkee not only helps show why T'Pol is such a fascinating member of the ENT universe, but she also extends my understanding of the rest of the crew. Even Porthos!
-- Kelly Chambliss - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 19:08:50 -0400

86In the Course of Justice by Penny Proctor
I'm a sucker for Penny's legal stories, and this one ranks among her best. I'm awed by her range of precisely, perceptively-delineated characters, from major figures down to the leftover members of the Equinox crew. Penny is a writer of grace and depth, as this story, with its many layers and its skillful style, perfectly demonstrates.
-- Kelly Chambliss - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 19:12:07 -0400

93It Must Have Slipped My Mind by Paula Stiles
I really enjoyed Paula's entire drabble series, and for a moment, I wavered between choosing this one and going for the one with Khan. But then, I just couldn't pass up this excellent Janeway/Kashyk. The tightness of the drabble form works perfectly for the tension and power-plays of this relationship. As the surprising-yet-inevitable last line shows, less really is more.
-- Kelly Chambliss - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 19:17:18 -0400

2Janeway: The Musical! by Jemima
I adored Jemima's "The Sounds of Sickbay," but for my money, nothing tops my favorite filk of the year, "Janeway: The Musical." The poetry scans, it's funny, it's in character, and the different pieces come together in a unified whole. Everything works so well that I have a hard time believing that the original wasn't written with the VOY characters in mind.
-- Kelly Chambliss - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 19:20:27 -0400

10Kindred Spirits by Gamin Davis
I haven't read Gamin's fiction before this year, but I'm glad I didn't miss "Kindred Spirits." As a crossover, it works really well; I like the way Gamin draws out the parallels as well as differences between Janeway and Kirk and between Tuvok and Spock.
-- Kelly Chambliss - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 19:22:59 -0400

65Pot Kettle Black by the stylus
In a way, I'm glad the stylus didn't write more this year, because it would have been very difficult to choose just one of her stories as a favorite. This Janeway, Gretchen would definitely have been in the running, though: it brings together the powerful style and perception that make the stylus's stories such a treat.
-- Kelly Chambliss - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 19:26:30 -0400

90Saving Strangers by janezy
I know I've mentioned before how impressed I am by the way janezy presents both the Admiral Janeway/Chakotay relationship and the characters of Admiral and Captain. I like her Chakotay, who can see past the surface to recognize the continuity of "Kathryn," and I like both Janeways, especially the Admiral, who, despite the ethical problems associated with her time travel, is the same sexy, thoughtful explorer who captivated me as far back as "Caretaker."
-- Kelly Chambliss - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 19:30:17 -0400

108Stockholm Syndrome by nostalgia
No question about which nostalgia story I liked best this year. The multiple layers and contradictions of this very believable Seven still impress me. Many writers, myself included, present Seven as either mostly human or mostly alien. Few of us do what nostalgia does so well here: give us a Seven who is BOTH human and alien together. The characterization is both chilling and moving.
-- Kelly Chambliss - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 19:34:02 -0400

5The Albatross by Christinecgb
Actually, my choice for favorite Christine story of the year is a tie: I love both "The Albatross" and "Accidental Suicide." But since I am allowing myself to vote for only one story per author, I give the slight edge to "The Albatross" because only a very skillful writer can still make me believe in a Janeway/Chakotay relationship, even an ansgty one. And Christine's albatross metaphor is evocative and expressive.
-- Kelly Chambliss - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 19:37:38 -0400

57Tourniquet by Kat
I was initially skeptical about the pairing of Janeway/Crusher, but in Kat's sure hands, it works beautifully. I like seeing Janeway's point of view, and I'm glad that Kat has been able to make me see Crusher as so much more than merely Wesley's mother and a source of sexual tension for Picard. As Kat shows, these are both strong, able, and lovable women who don't have to make excuses for their power or their confidence.
-- Kelly Chambliss - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 19:41:36 -0400

34An Elegant Solution by Rocky
Choosing just one "favorite" story by Rocky is hard enough in general, let alone during the "Glory Days" year. Yet here I am, about to cast my "favorite Rocky story" vote for a piece that isn't even in the Glory Days universe. But "An Elegant Solution" stands out for me because it's such a good example of Rocky's skill at creating pitch-perfect voices for essentially minor characters such as Admiral Nechayev. Through these characters, she also manages to convey so much about the larger canon universe and its major players. However, even though I've chosen my favorite, I do want to mention my "Rocky Runners-Up" -- "Stand By Me," "Night Visitor," "The Foolish and the Brave," and "Glory Days."
-- Kelly Chambliss - Wed, 30 Apr 2003 19:46:20 -0400